Real vs Fake Opals: How to Tell the Difference and Avoid Imitations

Opals are among the most captivating gemstones, renowned for their unique play of color that shimmers across the surface. Their iridescence, which displays flashes of rainbow hues, is truly mesmerizing. However, with the rise of synthetic and imitation opals flooding the market, it can be tricky to differentiate between a real vs fake opals. Whether you’re a collector, a jewelry enthusiast, or simply someone interested in purchasing an opal, knowing how to spot the real deal is crucial.

In this blog, we’ll explore the key differences between real vs fake opals. By understanding these distinctions, you can make an informed decision the next time you’re shopping for this stunning gemstone.

1. Real vs Fake Opals: Look at the Play of Color

The most distinct feature of a genuine opal is its play of color. This refers to the shifting rainbow hues that appear when the opal is moved in the light. These colors result from the opal’s internal structure, which diffracts light as it hits the stone. In genuine opals, this play of color is often vivid and multi-dimensional, creating a smooth, shifting quality that changes with movement.

In contrast, fake opals typically exhibit a less dynamic, more uniform color. While synthetic and imitation opals may sparkle, they fail to replicate the same complexity and depth of color found in natural opals.

2. Real vs Fake Opals: Check the Surface Appearance

Genuine opals often have an organic, natural appearance, complete with subtle imperfections. Upon closer inspection, you might notice tiny inclusions or cracks, which are characteristic of natural stones. These inclusions are signs that the opal formed naturally under specific conditions over time, contributing to its unique beauty.

In contrast, imitation opals—whether made of glass or resin—are usually flawless, lacking any internal inclusions or irregularities. The surface of fake opals is typically smooth and overly polished, devoid of the natural texture and character that real opals possess.

3. Real vs Fake Opals: Examine the Weight

Opals are relatively heavy stones compared to their synthetic counterparts, and this weight difference is quite noticeable. Genuine opals have a density that sets them apart from imitation materials like glass or plastic. When you hold a stone in your hand, a real opal will feel heavier and more substantial than a fake opal of the same size.

If you’re uncertain about the weight, try comparing the opal to other gemstones of similar size. While this may not provide an immediate answer, it can help you get a better sense of the difference in weight.

4. Check for the “Dimple” Test

One of the simplest ways to tell if an opal is real or fake is by performing a basic “dimple test.” First, use a magnifying loupe (a small handheld magnifier) to closely examine the surface of the stone. A genuine opal will often display tiny dimples or “bumps” on its surface, which result from the stone’s natural formation process.

On the other hand, fake opals typically have a smooth, flawless surface with no visible dimples or irregularities. These surface-level imperfections are one of the key indicators of authenticity.

5. Observe the Opal’s Temperature

Like many natural stones, opals tend to feel cooler to the touch compared to plastic or glass imitation stones. When you place a genuine opal on your skin or the back of your hand, it will retain a cool temperature for a longer time.

In contrast, imitation opals made of plastic or resin warm up quickly to your body temperature. This temperature difference can be an easy way to help determine if the opal is real or fake.

6. Price Can Be a Clue

While price should never be the only determining factor, it can provide valuable insight into the authenticity of the stone. Genuine opals, particularly those with vibrant color play, rarity, and high-quality craftsmanship, are typically more expensive than synthetic counterparts. Therefore, if you come across a “too-good-to-be-true” deal, it’s essential to be cautious—there’s a good chance the opal is an imitation.

7. Examine the Back of the Stone

Sometimes, the back of an opal can reveal whether it’s real or fake. Natural opals typically have a slightly rougher, uneven surface at the back, especially if they were cut from opal rough rather than being manufactured in a lab. This natural texture is a key indicator of authenticity.

In contrast, synthetic opals often have a smoother, more uniform appearance at the back of the stone. Additionally, some synthetic stones may feature a specific pattern or serial number etched onto the back to indicate they are man-made.

Conclusion

Opals are undeniably beautiful, and when purchased correctly, they can be a valuable addition to any jewelry collection. Whether you’re buying an opal for its stunning beauty or as an investment, it’s crucial to distinguish between real and fake opals. By carefully considering the play of color, surface appearance, weight, and other factors discussed above, you’ll be well-equipped to identify a genuine opal from an imitation.

Moreover, always ensure you’re purchasing from a reputable source. Don’t hesitate to ask questions or request certificates of authenticity. With a bit of knowledge, you can confidently enjoy and protect your precious opal.

Check Out Our Collection Today!